October 2005 Vol. 104 No. 1 THE REVIEW

A Prudential Exercise: Abstention and the Probate Exception to Federal Diversity Jurisdiction

Christian J. Grostic

Ann-Marie Brege’s parents established an irrevocable trust in 1985, with Ann-Marie as sole beneficiary. When Merrill Lynch Trust Co. took over as trustee years later, however, the trust’s principal dropped sharply, losing over half its value in just a few years. Ann-Marie sued in Michigan probate court, alleging that Merrill Lynch had violated its legal duties in administering the trust. Since Ann-Marie was from New York and Merrill Lynch had its head-quarters in New Jersey, Merrill Lynch had an apparently easy argument for diversity jurisdiction. In an unremarkable turn of events, Merrill Lynch filed a notice of removal to federal district court.

Ann-Marie didn’t take Merrill Lynch’s removal sitting down. She filed a motion to remand to state probate court, arguing, inter alia, that the federal court lacked subject matter jurisdiction because of the probate exception to federal jurisdiction. Merrill Lynch was taken aback—no court, Merrill Lynch argued, had ever applied the probate exception to a case that didn’t involve a will, estate, or some equivalent substitute. The federal court brushed Merrill Lynch’s argument aside and instead followed a line of case law that looks to the jurisdiction of probate courts under state law to determine the extent of the probate exception. Finding that Michigan gave its probate courts exclusive jurisdiction over claims involving the administration of trusts, the court granted Ann-Marie’s motion to remand.

   //  VIEW PDF
& Other Current Events

Judicial Diversity After Shelby County v. Holder

In 2014, voters in ten of the fifteen states previously covered by the Voting Rights Act ("VRA") preclearance...

Fall Submission Season

MLR’s Articles Office will open its fall submission season on Monday, August 18!  The Articles...

The Ninth Circuit's Treatment of Sexual Orientation: Defining “Rational Basis Review with Bite”

On February 10, Nevada's Democratic attorney general decided to stop defending the state's constitutional...

Inhibiting Intrastate Inequalities: A Congressional Approach to Ensuring Equal Opportunity to Finance Public Education

The United States has exhibited a strong commitment to public education throughout its history. The local...

War Is Governance: Explaining the Logic of the Laws of War from a Principal-Agent Perspective

What is the purpose of the international law on armed conflict, and why would opponents bent on destroying...
MAILING LIST
Sign Up to Join Our Mailing List