March 2013 Vol. 111 No. 5 THE REVIEW

Policeman, Citizen, or Both? A Civilian Analogue Exception to Garcetti v. Ceballos

Caroline A. Flynn

The First Amendment prohibits the government from leveraging its employment relationship with a public employee in order to silence the employee’s speech. But the Supreme Court dramatically curtailed this right in Garcetti v. Ceballos by installing a categorical bar: if the public employee spoke “pursuant to her official duties,” her First Amendment retaliation claim cannot proceed. Garcetti requires the employee to show that she was speaking entirely “as a citizen” and not at all “as an employee.” But this is a false dichotomy—especially because the value of the employee’s speech to the public is no less if she is speaking pursuant to mixed motivations.

A recent Second Circuit case, Jackler v. Byrne, suggests an exception to Garcetti’s categorical bar. Because the public employee’s speech in Jackler had a civilian analogue—that is, because an ordinary citizen could speak in the same manner and to the same audience—the court allowed the employee’s claim to proceed. The Second Circuit’s exception contradicts Garcetti, but it furthers significant First Amendment values while adequately protecting public employers’ interest in controlling employee speech. As such, the Supreme Court should adopt the civilian analogue exception to ameliorate Garcetti’s problematic rule.

   //  VIEW PDF
& Other Current Events

Crawford v. Washington: A Ten Year Retrospective

No one disputes the significance of Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36 (2004), which fundamentally transformed Confrontation...

Come Back to the Boat, Justice Breyer!

I want to get Justice Breyer back on the right side of Confrontation Clause issues. In 1999, in Lilly...

Crawford v. Washington: The Next Ten Years

Imagine a world . . . in which the Supreme Court got it right the first time. That is,...

The Crawford Debacle

First a toast-to my colleague Jeff Fisher and his Crawford compatriot, Richard Friedman, on the...

Confrontation and the Re-Privatization of Domestic Violence

When the Supreme Court transformed the right of confrontation in Crawford v. Washington, the prosecution...
MAILING LIST
Sign Up to Join Our Mailing List