November 2011 Vol. 110 No. 2 THE REVIEW

Shutting the Back Door: Using American Needle to Cure the Problem of Improper Product Definition

Daniel A. Schwartz

Section 1 of the Sherman Act is designed to protect competition by making illegal any agreement that has the effect of limiting consumer choice. To make this determination, courts first define the product at issue and then consider the challenged restraint's impact on the market in which that product competes. When considering § 1 allegations against sports leagues, courts have tended to define products according to the structure of the leagues. The result of this tendency is that harm to competition between the leagues' teams is not properly accounted for in the courts' analyses. This, in turn, grants leagues a form of immunity to which they are not entitled under any statutory or doctrinal rule.

In reaching this conclusion, this Note reviews the business structure of sports leagues and explains why they present such a difficult challenge for courts. It then examines a number of cases in which courts, struggling with those challenges, improperly defined the product according to league structure. For each case, the Note explains the mistake that was made and how that mistake granted leagues de facto immunity. This Note concludes by arguing that the Supreme Court's recent decision in American Needle can serve as the impetus for correcting this mistake if courts broadly interpret the meaning of the case by looking to the logic that animates it.

   //  VIEW PDF
& Other Current Events

The Tools of Political Dissent: A First Amendment Guide to Gun Registries

On December 23, 2012, a newspaper in upstate New York published a provocative map. On it appeared...

Cultivating Inclusion

Twenty-five years ago, law schools were in the developing stages of a pitched battle for the future of legal...

Aftermarketfailure: Windows XP's End of Support

"After 12 years, support for Windows XP will end on April 8, 2014." So proclaims a Microsoft website with...

Globally Speaking—Honoring the Victims' Stories: Matsuda's Human Rights Praxis

Globally speaking, international law and the vast majority of domestic legal systems strive to protect...

Toward A Multiple Consciousness of Language: A Tribute to Professor Mari Matsuda

I am thrilled to be part of this commemoration of the twenty-fifth anniversary of Professor Matsuda's...
MAILING LIST
Sign Up to Join Our Mailing List